Thursday, 12 October 2017 | MYT 2:26 PM
Taiwan fines Qualcomm US$774mil for antitrust violations
HONG KONG: Qualcomm Inc faces an antitrust fine in Taiwan, the latest in a years-long streak of regulatory setbacks to its business model that comes as it also fights US regulators and iPhone maker Apple Inc in court over many of the same legal issues.
The Taiwan Fair Trade Commission said on Oct 11 that it would fine Qualcomm T$23.4bil (US$774.14mil / RM3.27bil) for anti-trust violations of its chip technology.
The Commission said in a Chinese-language statement that Qualcomm had a monopoly over the chip market for several so-called modem technologies, which provide wireless data connectivity for mobile phones, and refused to licence its technology to other industry players.
In Taiwan, Qualcomm is required to submit a progress report on the matter every six months to the Commission on negotiations with related parties.
In a statement, Qualcomm said it disagreed with the decision. Once the final decision is issued in the coming weeks, Qualcomm said it will challenge the decision in court.
"The fine bears no rational relationship to the amount of Qualcomm's revenues or activities in Taiwan, and Qualcomm will appeal the amount of the fine and the method used to calculate it," Qualcomm said.
The Taiwanese decision is the latest challenge to Qualcomm's business model, which involves selling chips and also licensing a suite of patents related to how those chips are put into a phone to provide mobile data to the device. While the regulatory and legal attacks differ in some details, a key theme is the allegation that Qualcomm uses its dominant position in the market for modem chips to charge unfair royalty rates for its patents.
Last December, Korean regulators fined Qualcomm US$854mil (RM3.6bil) for violating its competition laws, a ruling that followed an US$975mil (RM4.11bil) fine from Chinese regulators in 2015.
European regulators have also expressed antitrust concerns over Qualcomm's US$38bil (RM160.17bil) bid to buy NXP Semiconductors.
The US Federal Trade Commission is also suing Qualcomm over its licensing practices.
Those regulatory challenges are playing out as Apple is waging a global legal battle on Qualcomm's long-held practice of charging a percentage of the total price of iPhones and other Apple devices as a licensing fee for its patents.
After those lawsuits were filed, Qualcomm brought an action against Apple before the US International Trade Commission seeking to ban imports of some iPhones. Qualcomm filed a separate civil lawsuit accusing Apple of infringing the patents at issue in that action. — Reuters